Sorting through the pros and cons of both pneumatic and electric power tools can be a challenge, but there are some clear differences between the two.
Recognizing these differences and comparing them to your own needs should give you the answers you’re looking for and we’ll lay those out for you below.
Air Tools vs. Electric: Our Overall Verdict
While both pneumatic and electric tools have their advantages, we feel today’s electric power tools have largely caught up to air tools in terms of power. You might get a little more torque from a pneumatic tool, but you sacrifice a lot in mobility.
For the best combination of power, performance, price, comfort, level of tech, ease of use and safety factors we think electric power tools are the way to go in 2023.
A few years ago the answer to which type of tool gives you better overall performance would have been much simpler. There was a time not too long ago when electric power tools simply couldn’t compete with pneumatic power tools for overall punch and torque.
That’s why these types of tools have been the go-to solutions for industrial and auto shops for decades.
As our technology has advanced so have the reliability and performance of electric power tools. They may not have quite as much zip as their pneumatic cousins, but the gap is closing rapidly.
This isn’t just limited to corded electric power tools either. Modern battery-powered tools have better longevity, level of power and they also weigh a lot less than they used to.
If you’re willing to spend the money, you can find a battery-operated power tool in just about any category that rivals its pneumatic counterpart for overall performance and you can take it with you anywhere once it’s fully charged.
In terms of the actual price that you’ll pay for each tool, it’s not even close. Pneumatic tools are considerably cheaper than their electric cousins. Considering how much torque and power you can achieve with a pneumatic tool, that may leave you wondering why there’s even a debate about which tool you should choose for your own use.
There’s one key factor that closes the price gap rapidly – you simply can’t use a pneumatic tool without an air compressor and a good compressor can be quite expensive.
Check out our picks for the best air compressors for home use.
This means the overall cost of use for a pneumatic tool is more expensive than it is if you opt for electric power tools.
The upfront costs are more at the very least, although the maintenance costs of pneumatic tools are less as they have fewer moving parts.
Still, even taking that into consideration the electric tools are probably cheaper in the long run.
Comfort and Feel Factor
The great thing about pneumatic tools is that they are extremely lightweight – you don’t need to be muscle-bound to operate them and they generally feel pretty comfortable when you grip them.
Compared to the electric power tools and in particular, the battery-operated models just a few short years ago, this was no contest. Pneumatic power tools won the contest for comfort and feel with ease.
In 2023 things are a little murkier. Battery technology has come a long way in the last decade or so and that has closed the gap between the two types of tools on this issue.
Battery cells are much smaller, the battery lasts longer and that makes these types of tools a lot easier to operate and more comfortable to use than ever before.
How Does the Tech Hold Up?
When we think about pneumatic tools we usually picture industrial-strength tools that are built with power and torque in mind, not a tool that’s packed full of the latest technology. That’s just not true with the latest generation of pneumatic tools on the market today.
In 2023, they often come equipped with Bluetooth technology that allows you to access stats on various things such as torque and air levels right to an app on your smartphone.
While it’s nice to know that you can now access diagnostic tools right on your cell phone with the latest pneumatic tools that doesn’t give them an advantage over electric power tools.
The latest electric tools are full of technological capability including access to diagnostic stats on an app on your phone.
They can also tell you how much charge you have left and let you know if there are any performance issues with your electric tool.
Ease of Use
In the ease of use category, electric power tools are a clear winner. They may have more moving parts, inside them, but you don’t have to hook them up to an air compressor, constantly monitor air pressure or hook up any extra hoses to get started.
All you need is a reliable power source either in the form of a battery pack or an electrical outlet.
They also tend to be a lot more mobile. A good compressor is heavy and cumbersome and that means you’re limited in where you can use your tools. Most of the time you have to work inside your shop, or at least out front of your shop if you have longer hoses.
A corded electric power tool will work inside or outside wherever there’s an available outlet and a battery-powered tool can go just about anywhere you want it to.
One final factor to consider when using power tools is how safe they are to operate. Pneumatic tools can be cumbersome and a bit awkward to use because you always have to be attached to a hose that hooks up to your compressor.
Those hose lines are usually thicker than a power cord to give you the torque you need from your compressor and that also means you have to be careful not to trip on the hoses while you work.
Electric corded power tools, by contrast, are usually attached to thinner electrical cords which are relatively easy to avoid if you’re careful and when you choose a battery-powered power tool this isn’t an issue at all.